Mainframe Community Reacts to Dramatic Reorganization Proposal
Analyst Steven Dickens sparked debate and pushback last week by proposing the consolidation of SHARE, GS UK, GSE and others
The mainframe community’s organizational structure came under scrutiny last week as an industry analyst’s open letter set off a debate over the ecosystem’s future.
Steven Dickens’ letter, which drew responses from some of the industry’s most prominent leaders after being posted on LinkedIn Nov. 9, called for the major groups comprising the mainframe community to consolidate under one organization. Under this vision, SHARE, GS UK, GSE, IDUG and VM Workshop would dissolve and become part of an organizing body run by Linux Foundation Events.
That same organization runs KubeCon, which Dickens cited as inspiration for his proposal, publishing his letter as the cloud-native conference kicked off. “Spending the week with the cloud native community always makes me think about the fragmentation in the mainframe world and how the cloud-native world has its act together,” he wrote.
‘SHARE Is Dying’
Dickens, CEO and principal analyst at HyperFRAME Research, offered a dire prognosis for the mainframe community’s largest conference. “SHARE is dying,” he wrote.
In response, Cynthia Overby, SHARE Association president, cited the organization’s favorable financial position. “We’re solid fiscally,” Overby told TechChannel.
But in Dickens’ assessment, the mainframe community is losing money because the conference is run by a for-profit company, Smithbucklin. That amounts to what Dickens called a “fragmentation tax,” which he contrasted with his proposal. “All of that money in my model goes back into the community because the Linux Foundation runs all that for free,” he told TechChannel.
Under Dickens’ model, Linux Foundation Events would run two flagship mainframe events every year under a new banner, MainframeCon—one in Europe every March and one in North America every September. Those conferences would debut in 2028, with a satellite MainframeCon Asia debuting in 2029.
But the mainframe community does not revolve around in-person events alone, Overby noted, observing that new mainframers are looking for year-round programming, not just one-off events. “They’re looking for that ongoing connectivity. Where can I go when I’ve got a problem, when I need somebody to talk to, that kind of thing. And so our focus is really going to be around year-round education going forward,” she said.
That includes expanded access to SHARE’s online education platform in addition to expanded geographical reach. In January, for the first time, SHARE will partner with the IBM Power user group, COMMON, to host a conference in Bengaluru, India, where Broadcom, BMC, IBM and Rocket have large development centers, Overby noted.
That partnership is one example of a consolidation trend that is already underway. Beginning next year, SHARE is transitioning from its twice-annual conference format to one conference per year. And at TechXchange in October, COMMON and the Db2 user group IDUG both co-located conferences within IBM’s flagship technical gathering. SHARE was invited to be a part of TechXchange as well, but turned down the invite in part due to limited preparation time, Overby said.
Further consolidation, in Dickens’ view, would create a better “front door” for would-be mainframers who might otherwise not know where to turn as they try to join the community. Those potential entry points include SHARE, GS Forge, GSE and vendor events, plus LinkedIn groups, YouTube channels, Discord servers, podcasts and newsletters. “Nobody here is the villain,” Dickens wrote. “But taken together, the result is a maze.”
Consolidation Plan Gets Pushback
In addition to the long-established user groups Dickens mentioned in his proposal, he also envisioned absorbing the digital assets of the for-profit Mainframe Society, an online community that has amassed 13,000 followers on LinkedIn since its founding in 2019. But like SHARE, Mainframe Society is not on board with Dickens’ idea.
Henri Kuiper, cofounder of the venture, made that clear in an open letter responding to Dickens’ manifesto. In a letter titled “Connect, Don’t Consolidate,” Kuiper argued that the various entities comprising the mainframe community all serve their own purposes and would be constrained by being a part of a larger organization.
“They have different histories, audiences, personalities and purposes,” he wrote. “Some are focused on deep technical knowledge sharing. Others are about networking, education, advocacy, open source or simply bringing people together. That’s not something I’d be particularly keen to throw away.”
In Kuiper’s estimation, Dickens’ plan would create a monolithic organization that would stymie these independent groups’ freedom. “If it’s all one, there is no competition, there is no growth, there is no innovation,” he told TechChannel.
It’s better to have several nimble, independent groups, he added. “It’s so much better, in my personal belief, than a big, I’d almost call it slow, enterprisey, large thing … because then the world changes so, so fast, and I think you need to be able to adapt fast, to try new things, to see what works for your community.”
Dickens argued that under his proposal, the same people running existing mainframe community organizations would also be in charge of the consolidated organization he envisions. “I’m just saying there is a slicker, better backend for all of this,” he said. “This is not a land grab to try and replace any of those people. In fact, it’s the exact opposite. It’s unlocking a cheat code for those people to be more successful.”
Reduce the Vendor Focus?
One way Dickens is hoping to enhance the appeal of mainframe events is to make them less vendor-centric. An unfavorable ratio of vendors to practitioners has caused SHARE to devolve into a conference that amounts to “vendors talking to each other,” he observed.
Taking aim at “pay to play” speaking slots that he says amount to sales presentations rather than technical discussions, Dickens’ plan calls for a review process in which 50% of presentations would come from end-user organizations.
Overby agreed that events being too vendor-focused is “a problem,” but not one solved by consolidation. The problem, she contends, is that customers (end users) are hesitant to send technologists to speak at conferences out of concern over intellectual property. “In order for a customer to be able to speak at a conference, they have to do it under their own name in most cases,” Overby said.
She stressed that SHARE, nevertheless, is dedicated to booking presentations from customers. “And so what we do is we basically say any customer presentation, no matter what it is, no matter who it is, we’re going to accept those. And then we have our two premier sponsors, Broadcom and IBM, who have contracts with us. They get a number of sessions that they’re allowed to do,” Overby said.
To get more customers presenting, “we’re going to provide incentives, free registration, that kind of thing. And we’ll see what happens.”
Shared Goal, Disputed Approach
While the LinkedIn comments section revealed substantial agreement that vendors are overrepresented at mainframe events, Dickens’ letter received considerable pushback overall. One common sentiment was that users and practitioners should be driving decisions about the mainframe community’s future instead of a top-down mandate. Also common was skepticism that a mainframe event could scale up to match Dickens’ vision while retaining a community feel.
“His heart is in the right place, I think, truly, honestly,” Overby said. “But he doesn’t have years and years and years of experience around building a global mainframe community and being able to provide what we call year-round education.”
Dickens, whose prominent profile in the mainframe community includes helping to establish the Linux Foundation’s Open Mainframe Project about 11 years ago, said he was well aware how far he was sticking his neck out. He also noted it’s a position he’s familiar with. “I stuck my neck out when I created the Open Mainframe Project. I’ve advocated for this community for 15 years,” he said.
He stressed that, aside from adding to his 16,000 LinkedIn followers, he had nothing to gain by posting the letter. “I’ve got nothing to win in this situation. In fact, I’ve got stuff to lose because I might’ve pissed a few people off,” he said, adding that he issued the critique on his own. “Nobody asked me to do this.”
TechChannel reached out to the Open Mainframe Project for this article, but the organization declined to comment. Leadership from GSE, GS UK, IDUG and VM Workshop also declined to comment.
Dickens made at least one assertion in his letter that even critics of his proposal are likely to agree with: “The platform has never been more relevant. It runs the world’s banks, airlines, and governments, and it is taking on AI workloads that nobody would have predicted ten years ago.”
Overby concurs: “Mainframes run the world.”